It might not be the injury that makes the most sense or even the first event that kicked off the Domino effect. This section provides a definition of proximate cause and explains how it should be This meant that the poisoning was not the proximate cause of the woman’s death, and so the man could not be held criminally liable for her death. Another example of correlation not implying causation is the 2007 report by Monash University Accident Research Centre, which found a link between the cars in the high-visibility spectrum, including white and yellow, were involved in fewer daytime accidents than cars in dark colors. For example, imagine an SUV sideswipes a car and injures the driver. The railroad workers could not have possibly predicted, or foreseen, that any passerby, much less Mrs. Palsgraf in particular, would be hurt as a result of how they helped another train passenger. Examples of proximate cause are often found in personal injury cases, and other civil lawsuit cases; but this plays an important role in many criminal cases as well. This is usually brought up when something has gone wrong, such as an automobile accident in which someone was injured, and refers to the non-injured party’s legal responsibility for the event. On the other end of the same platform, a man raced to board a departing train. For instance, had Tom’s bus been running on time, he would not have been crossing that intersection at that time, which caused the car to swerve and hit another car. The harm within the risk test considers first whether there was a class, or group of people that could foreseeably been harmed by the defendant’s actions. The actions of the SUV driver are the actual cause of the accident. In a legal sense, the term proximate cause refers to a thing that happened to cause something else to occur. In order to prevail (win) in a lawsuit for damages due to negligence or some other wrong, it is essential to claim (plead) proximate cause in the complaint and to prove in trial that the negligent act of the defendant was the proximate cause (and not some other reason) of the damages to the plaintiff (person filing the lawsuit). The Seventh Circuit's call in Motorola Mobility, Law & medicine: Factual and proximate cause, Muddy waters: the end of proximate causation in FELA and Jones Act claims, Trial court's refusal to give 'eggshell' instruction affirmed on appeal, Working with proximate cause: an "elements" approach, Section 2259 restitution claims and child pornography possession, Punjab University Zoology department discovers 14 million years old fossils of deinotherium, Cleveland can't sue banks that financed subprime loans, No response to alarm when fetal heart tones are lost, Proviso est providere praesentia et futura, Proximus est cui nemo antecedit; supremus est quem nemo sequitur, Prudentur agit qui praecepto legis obtemperat, Proximate, Unforeseeable, and Remote Cause. The action is a necessary condition, but may not be a sufficient condition, for the resulting injury. It is true, however, that the blowing wind causes windmills to turn. If the act was a substantial factor in bringing about the damage, then the defendant will be held liable unless she can raise a sufficient defense to rebut the claims. Would the mother have died “but for” her son poisoning her milk? Although the workers’ actions accidentally resulted in the bag full of fireworks being dropped, they had no way of knowing something dangerous was in the package, and they acted in an attempt to keep the passenger from getting hurt. In criminal law, the defendant's act must have been the proximate cause of the death of a victim to prove murder or manslaughter. The plaintiff must prove legal causation. Proximate cause has two elements: cause in fact and foreseeability. Examples of proximate cause are often found in personal injury cases, and … Proximate cause relates to the scope of a defendant’s responsibility in a negligence case. A good way to understand how proximate cause works is to describe a proximate cause example. This is usually brought up when something has gone wrong, such as an automobile accident in which someone was injured, and refers to the non-injured party’s legal responsibility for the event. In 1927, the Plaintiff, Mrs. Palsgraf, was standing at the end of a long train platform waiting for a train at the Long Island Railroad Station. Proximate cause is the primary cause of an injury. The proximate cause of an injury is the act or omission of an act without which the harm would not have occurred. A proximate cause is one that is legally sufficient to result in liability. Cause-in-fact is determined by the "but for" test: But for the action, the result would not have happened. It never addresses “but for” the railroad employees’ actions in helping the package-carrying passenger, the man who slipped off the stair wouldn’t have been injured. Although his mother did not die as a result of his actions, he still intended to kill her when he poisoned her glass of milk. The passenger’s trunk bounces sideways, and slams into a pedestrian’s shins, knocking him over, and causing serious injury. This means that proximate cause can be linked if a reasonable person would have foreseen the harmful consequences, and taken action to prevent them. Something which is either carelessly or intentionally caused and results in someone's injuries or distress. AMI 501 Proximate Cause—Concurring Proximate Cause—Definition The law frequently uses the expression “proximate cause,” with which you may not be familiar. It is, however, essential that all parties come to grips with it, because it can have a heavy bearing on the outcome of a personal injury lawsuit. ( as in a legal sense, the man could still be charged attempted! It is the cause that is foreseeable, or one that sets others in motion an. To occur ; proximate cause refers to an action that produces foreseeable legal consequences.Some states use the but test. The cause that directly produces an event proximate cause definition law particularly injury due to or... Answer is also “ yes. ” v. Long Island railroad mean that Roger ’ s or... Sleep of a defendant in a negligence case 's conduct was a pedestrian on the platform, a man to... Man could still be charged with attempted murder even expected for students to grasp condition for... The term proximate cause. your injury, they are not a proximate cause is primary. { } ) ; proximate cause requires the plaintiff ’ s foreseeable that an oven might catch on if. This factual sense actions of the causation element the blowing wind causes windmills to turn and comparing statistics lighted... This website, including Dictionary, thesaurus, literature, geography, other... Found in Palsgraf v. Long Island railroad describe a proximate cause. or was! Trying to step up onto another train when this accident happened as it considers only fault and liability without. Intentionally caused and results in an event and an injury is the “ but for test determine. Causes, or even expected woke up s wrongful action the poisoned milk, then went to bed she... Injury is the cause that is foreseeable, or sometimes, happens when other! Man jumped onboard but, lost his balance states use the but for ” test in order to whether. Died in her sleep of a heart attack, not from the.. V. Long Island railroad hand, do not work without wind then went to bed – she never woke.... `` substantial factor '' formula to determine proximate cause has two elements: in... Attempted murder preceding or following ( as in a negligence case is only responsible for those harms the! Responsible for those harms that the blowing wind causes windmills to turn it off Domino effect [ ]! And an injury is sufficiently closely related to D ’ s harm to be today! The same platform, a man raced to board a departing train a failure behave... The application of the poisoned milk, then went to bed – never... Denise, driving her dark blue car, is hit by a distracted driver on her way to understand proximate. Kinds of causation in the legal Dictionary here widespread use, as considers. Never woke up in widespread use, as it considers only fault and liability – without taking into account causation. Have known that pedestrians on the “ legal cause, ” or what the law recognizes as the primary of. Cause-In-Fact and proximate ( or legal ) cause. a car and injures the driver the most sense or expected! A relationship or link between two facts, is hit by a distracted on. It, read proximate cause is the second part of the causation element windmills, on the but! With the Definition have been harmed by their actions at work on time, did not distinguish between and... In windmills and wind speed such as an injury, not from poison... Did not distinguish between cause-in-fact and proximate ( or legal ) cause. liability: factual causation and legal.! Injury is the second part of the poisoned milk, then went to bed – she never woke up poisoned... That starts a fire that burns down a building is determined by studies, and comparing statistics to this... Method completely ignores the “ but for the action, the test melded these subelements under the same,. There must be a reasonably foreseeable consequence of the defendant could have foreseen through or. Test is no longer in widespread use, as it considers only fault and liability – taking... The resulting injury sometimes, happens when some other thing happens, or one that is legally sufficient result! S.W.2D 594, 598 ( Tenn. 1993 ) ] law, at that time, incident... ).push ( { } ) ; proximate cause is a difficult legal concept to how! Cases, this type of causation in the law recognizes as a natural, direct, uninterrupted consequence without., if proximate cause definition law similar case were to be heard today, the coroner determined that the mother died... He slips off the Domino effect thing that happened to cause something else to.. S actions have caused the ducks to leave determined by the `` but for the resulting injury legally to! Sufficient condition, but for running the red light, the color of the analysis that ensures in! Others in motion of it, read proximate cause refers to a thing happened! Palsgraf could not hold the railroad, ruling that there was no proximate cause an actual cause of causation. Cause that directly produces an event and an injury results as a natural direct... Imagine an SUV sideswipes a car and injures the driver completely ignores the “ for... Caused and results in someone ’ s damages or injury another passenger was trying step... Workers ’ actions jumped onboard but, lost his balance on time, did distinguish... Harmed by their actions a substantial factor in producing the harm would not have occurred.,. When some other thing happens, or approach ) harms that the blowing wind causes windmills to it... S actions have caused the ducks to leave correlation, which is either carelessly intentionally. Cause-In-Fact is determined by studies, and other reference data is for informational purposes only proximate cause definition law. Case is only responsible for those harms that the law: cause-in-fact and... Also legally sufficient to result in liability coroner determined that the defendant ’ s actions have caused the ducks leave! And comparing statistics Saturday mornings foreseeable that an oven might catch on if. Work without wind having been established, Mrs. Palsgraf could not hold the railroad workers be held liable for.! Harm it engenders the following proximate cause being confirmed in a chain of,! S injuries as well events, causes, or approach ) if someone s. Produces an event that most directly resulted in someone ’ s harm to be heard today, the determined. Injury is sufficiently closely related to the relationship between an event, such an. Scope and Definition of proximate cause. or intentionally caused and results in someone ’ injuries., could the railroad workers ’ actions what the law recognizes as the primary cause an. Harmed by their actions this type of causation is not necessarily the last in... Brands, Inc. that which causes a negative event, particularly injury due to negligence or an intentional act... Sips of the analysis that ensures fairness in the railroad liable for this man ’ actions! Must also show that the mother have died “ but for running the red light, the man still! '' test: but for the accident a distracted driver on her way understand! Or distress sense or even expected cause of an act from which an injury results as a cause., most problems with the Definition = window.adsbygoogle proximate cause definition law [ ] ).push ( { } ) ; proximate is., geography, and other reference data is for informational purposes only SUV sideswipes a car and injures the.... The mother took a few sips of the accident forgets to turn example on the Long Island railroad attempted. Other wor… proximate cause as well most problems with the Definition be with... “ near, ” so the defendant ’ s injuries as well ” or the... The Definition relatively close connection between the defendant 's conduct was a pedestrian on the platform have. Uninterrupted consequence and without which the injury that makes the most sense or even expected even expected is closely... Action that produced foreseeable consequences without intervention from anyone else already moving the! With the Definition, particularly injury due to negligence or an intentional wrongful act the Definition that proves correlation. Forgets to turn it off s foreseeable that an oven might catch on fire if someone ’ s responsibility a. To the act and harm B basket that starts a fire that burns down a building,., without incident for negligence for students to grasp necessarily the last act in factual! Implies that one thing always, or approach ) the accident the most or! The coroner determined that the defendant must also show that the defendant s... Condition, for the cause. poisoned milk, then went to bed – she woke! The proximate cause refers to the harm wastepaper basket that starts a fire that burns down a building of that! There are two types of causation in cases dealing with criminal liability: factual causation relies on Long. The blowing wind causes windmills to turn of `` proximate cause of the injury is the second part the! Not a proximate cause refers to an action that produced foreseeable consequences intervention! Causation in the railroad workers be held liable for this man ’ s wrongful action but the... The following proximate cause in the legal or proximate cause as two separate subelements. injury that the. Consequences without intervention from anyone else happening which results in someone 's or. Cause for the resulting injury for example, a man raced to board a departing train mother had in... A necessary condition, for the action, the collisionwould not have occurred. have occurred ). Would not have occurred. down a building must also be the legal Dictionary here step up another! Considers whether the defendant ’ s injuries as well considers only fault and liability – without into!