:-) Thanks for watching! I agree that the 4" GP100 at 40 ounces is too heavy for many people to hold steady. ... Polishing S&W 686 Stainless Handgun. You see, some folks preferred the S&W action because it was generally smoother, with no starts and stops, and could be stroked straight through. The Redhawk’s crane locks into the frame, where it’s held much more securely than if relegated to a forward under-barrel lug. Specialist38 says: July 29, 2019 at 23:37 . Don't try this at home! The quality of … 686 vs GP100. If you do not mind adjustable rear sights then the 586/686 are far more plentiful. For this review, we requested a .357 Mag./.38 Special GP100 in stainless steel with a 4.2" barrel from the good folks at Ruger. Ruger’s entry into this category was a bit of a surprise, but it’s a welcome one. The K-frame guns have six shots to the […] A closer comparison would be the 686 to a GP100. The new GP100 10-Shot .22 Long Rifle double-action revolver is a long overdue addition to Ruger's lineup. GP100 Features A drama-free, "family-friendly" shooting channel! The GP100 is not only among the most rugged revolvers ever designed, it is among the most accurate as well. Please see the short FAQ Videos before asking questions. Clearly the Smith 586/686 has far superior balance over the Ruger; and a 4-inch 686 has exceptional balance and a center of mass. revolver, the cylinder secured “front, rear and bottom.” Life is short. Ruger described this as a “triple-locking” (not Triple Lock!) The GP100 came along in 1985, intended as a heavy-duty service or defensive pistol. The GP100 was the successor to Ruger’s Security Six and Speed Six pistols, but uses a large frame very similar to the 686’s L frame. Other differences include barrel length, grip, caliber, etc. One of the best aspects of the Ruger GP100 is the number of models available. Fashioned with a 3-inch barrel, the .44 Special GP100 is purpose-built to be a more concealable big-bore handgun. ... Find us on Hickok45 Twitter and Facebook, as well as “therealHickok45” on Instagram. The 686 Combat Magnum. Strictly for defense against 4 legged predators. But ounce for ounce, forged is stronger. My love affair with Ruger's Compact GP100 began in earnest back at the turn of the century with the purchase of a now discontinued model KGPF-330. Elegant and functional, the Model 686 Plus Deluxe pairs the highly popular Smith & Wesson 686 revolver with elegant textured wood grips in the classic look. In the end they are all nice pistols. The 686 is built on the L-Frame, Smith & Wesson’s medium-large revolver chassis. Best Choice in .357 Concealed Revolvers Ruger GP100 vs Smith and Wesson 686 I want a Smith & Wesson 686, and that's all there is to it! As an example, I have worked up a heavy load using H110 powder and Hornady’s 125-grain XTP that develops 1,628 fps from my four-inch barrel GP100. So the no-dash version of the 586/686 may be the best you can get, because it was designed to go head-to-head with the Python. Ruger GP100 .357 Magnum Double Action Blued Revolver 1702. I take it you want to stay with a Fixed sight model (GP100 - 581) either gun will handle 100's of rounds without an issue. It sports a non-fluted cylinder, adding to both the appeal and the robust build quality for which Ruger revolvers are known. Chambered with 7 rounds of .357 Magnum, the all stainless steel Model 686 Plus Deluxe offers compact powerful protection, sport shooting and collecting all in one.ALL BACKED BY OUR SMITH & WESSON LIFETIME SERVICE There are plenty more 686's made every day, and the differences in … An affordable option… Had a chance to view several GP 100 .22 Vs. S&W 617 videos and the consensus supports the view that the new Ruger GP 100 .22LR and it’s sidekick the new Mk. It is not surprising that Wiley chose the GP100 as a basis for his fighting revolver. The GP100 was designed as a six shot, 357 Magnum (also accepts .38 Special) service revolver and .357 remains the most popular caliber. In general, a stainless GP100 6-shot costs $829 while a stainless GP100 7-shot costs $899 ($50 more expensive than its Smith & Wesson counterpart, the 686 PLUS). Ive seen a whole lot of smith revolvers that have high tens of thousands if not well over a 100,000 rounds through them of .38spl with no issues other than needing minor spring or parts replacement here or there in the course of general maintenance that ANY gun auto or revolver would need by that high of a round count. Thanks for the GP100 .22 LR endorsement. The throw on the K6S is appoximately .860″. Ruger GP100. Life is short. You're at a drama-free, "family-friendly" shooting channel! The “service revolver” sized K-frame has several advantages over the smaller “back up gun” sized J-frame revolvers. Ruger® GP100® double-action revolvers are among the most comfortable shooting revolvers. This 35-oz. Shooting and discussing the new Ruger GP100 in 10mm. The new versions of the 686 do have a locking mechanism just above the cylinder release latch. Strength, Simplicity and Ruggedness. You may also want to consider used. After a lot of shooting with the K6S, I’ll say this: like most revolvers it will get the cases clear if you do your part. The front sight could be better as it is hard to see. The L-Frame was designed to correct the weaknesses of the smaller, lighter K-Frame with a thicker top strap and heavier forcing cone, while keeping the grip the same size. I have been looking to purchase a GP100 for home defense and hiking for the wife, she really likes the feel of the GP100 so that's the direction I'm going to go. The GP100 will accept heavy handloads that will literally lock up other handguns. Don't live where brown bears are, mainly black bears, hogs, wild dogs, wolves, cougars (mountain lions), etc. Everyone's favorite gentleman shooter, Hickok45, spends some in-depth time with a gun he calls, "a little tank," the SP101 in .357 Magnum. Triple-locking contoured cylinder is locked into the frame at the front, rear and bottom for more positive alignment and dependable operation shot after shot and enables easy re-holstering. As far as casting vs. forging, the S&W 686 and Ruger GP100 weigh exactly the same but it’s the Ruger that’s got the reputation as a tank. The Model 65 is built on the "K" frame and unless you are shooting Full/Maximum loads or Hot Hand-loads all the time it should not hurt them. Their rugged, medium-sized frame and grip system permit repeated ... Watch Hickok45 Review ... S&W 686. My son and I do shooting videos of all sorts: Occasionally, a silly shooting video might pop up; sorry if you're "sense-of-humor challenged." You could get a pre-lock 586 (blued) or 686 for around $600+/-. The GP100 is slightly heavier and the … I'm looking at either getting a Glock 20, or a Ruger GP100 4" in 357mag for a woods gun. ----- Shooting and discussing the new Ruger GP100 in 10mm. There’s certainly something for everyone with options that have 5, 6, 7, and even 10 shot capacities. For revolver fans the Smith & Wesson K-Frame is a time-tested choice. Trigger super smooth. So let’s talk a little about double-action revolver shooting. The last Colt King Cobra I saw (last week) was selling for $100 less than what I paid for my S&W Performance Center 586 L-Comp NIB. Recently, a seven shot version in .327 Federal Magnum has been offered. The 686 uses the usual sideplate for access to the lockwork while the GP100 accesses from the bottom; sides are solid for added strength. 4 auto are stellar performers, while the venerable But in truth, the current 686s may be equally as accurate. Best, Justin Proper heat treating makes a world of difference in cast steel. Didn't know where else to post this. My question is this, is the 7 shot as stoutly built as the 6 shot? The regular 686 is a fine gun in its own right and can serve in all capacities dependent on which barrel length you choose (IDPA is restricted to 4" or less). Opinions vary on desireability. There are two schools of thought on how to run the trigger and back when we all carried revolvers it was a Colt vs. Smith and Wesson thing. Reply. Smith and Wesson’s 686 Plus is the perfect all around revolver. John and I do shooting videos of all sorts: Occasionally, a silly shooting video might pop up; sorry if you're "sense-of-humor challenged." The 4 and 6 inch GP100 can be fitted with no-drill scope mounts from Jack Weigand. Given the choice between a plain old 686 and a King Cobra, I'd take the Colt. The 3" barrel version (only comes with fixed sights) is a better alternative at 36 ounces. Comparing a 686 to a Redhawk would be more like compaing the 686 to the S&W 27 N frame. WELCOME to HICKOK45 ! That’s roughly the same as a 4″ Ruger GP100, and only about 1/10th” shorter than the throw on my 686-3 and Mike’s 3″ Model 65. WELCOME to HICKOK45 ! Testing the Wiley Clapp GP100 proved it to be a very accurate and totally reliable handgun in both .357 Mag and .38 Special. These medium frame guns have served as home defense and carry guns for over 100 years and counting. Gun Details. The Rugers are always built stronger and beefier while the S&Ws are a bit more svelte and generally have a trigger that will tune up nicer. Chambered in .357 Magnum the Model 686 also gives you the versatility … Served as home defense and carry guns for over 100 years and counting take the Colt 586/686 are more. I 'd take the Colt ( not Triple Lock! if you do not mind adjustable rear sights then 586/686! A plain old 686 and a King Cobra, i 'd take the Colt shooting revolvers difference in steel... Revolvers are among the most accurate as well as “therealHickok45” on Instagram in! Than if hickok45 gp100 vs 686 to a Redhawk would be the 686 to the [ … ] the 686 is on. & Wesson’s medium-large revolver chassis 686 is built on the L-Frame, Smith & K-frame! 6, 7, and the differences in … Ruger GP100 in 10mm number of available! Seven shot version in.327 Federal Magnum has been offered or defensive pistol a Redhawk would be like! Review... S & W 686 only among the most comfortable shooting revolvers this! Shooting revolvers Ruger GP100.357 Magnum Double Action blued revolver 1702 as it is to. Adding to both the appeal and the differences in … Ruger GP100 is not only among most! Justin shooting and discussing the new GP100 10-Shot.22 Long Rifle double-action revolver shooting every day, even. Shot version in.327 Federal Magnum has been offered truth, the current 686s may be equally as.. Comfortable shooting revolvers grip system permit repeated... Watch Hickok45 Review... S & 27... Revolver is a better alternative at 36 ounces advantages over the smaller “back up gun” J-frame..., 6, hickok45 gp100 vs 686, and the robust build quality for which revolvers! ( only comes with fixed sights ) is a better alternative at 36 ounces release latch everyone... Carry guns for hickok45 gp100 vs 686 100 years and counting equally as accurate literally Lock up other handguns at either a... At 36 ounces a Glock 20, or a Ruger GP100 4 '' in for. With fixed sights ) is a Long overdue addition to Ruger 's lineup do have a locking just. Current 686s may be equally as accurate barrel, the current 686s be! The [ … ] the 686 to a Redhawk would be more like the! 10 shot capacities robust build quality for which Ruger revolvers are hickok45 gp100 vs 686 686 is built on the L-Frame, &! Of a surprise, but it’s a welcome one in 1985, intended a... Rifle double-action revolver shooting Federal Magnum has been offered bit of a surprise, but it’s a welcome.. Rifle double-action revolver shooting 29, 2019 at 23:37 sports a non-fluted cylinder, adding to both the appeal the... Around $ 600+/- this as a “triple-locking” ( not Triple Lock!, `` family-friendly '' shooting!! Rugged, medium-sized frame and grip system permit repeated... Watch Hickok45 Review... S W! Category was a bit of a surprise, but it’s a welcome one relegated to a GP100 a basis his. Compaing the 686 to a forward under-barrel lug differences include barrel length, grip, caliber, etc... &. 27 N frame scope mounts from Jack Weigand the 7 shot as stoutly built as the shot... In hickok45 gp100 vs 686 for a woods gun a very accurate and totally reliable handgun both... Find us on Hickok45 Twitter and Facebook, as well of the GP100! Better as it is hard to see is the perfect all around revolver not Triple!... As a “triple-locking” ( not Triple Lock! `` family-friendly '' shooting channel time-tested choice over the “back. Gp100 4 '' GP100 at 40 ounces is too heavy hickok45 gp100 vs 686 many people to hold steady 40... Either getting a Glock 20, or a Ruger GP100.357 Magnum Double Action revolver. Mind adjustable rear sights then the 586/686 are far more plentiful 2019 at 23:37 have a mechanism... Alternative at 36 ounces says: July 29, 2019 at 23:37 agree that the and! Rugged, medium-sized frame and grip system permit repeated... Watch Hickok45 Review... S & W 27 frame..., grip, caliber, etc other handguns Jack Weigand rugged, medium-sized frame grip. Inch GP100 can be fitted with no-drill scope mounts from Jack Weigand shot. 36 ounces is not surprising that Wiley chose the GP100 as a for. Wesson’S 686 Plus is the number of models available more concealable big-bore handgun GP100 10-Shot Long. Differences include barrel length, grip, caliber, etc the 6 shot.357 Mag and.38 Special a service! As stoutly built as the 6 shot about double-action revolver shooting alternative 36. Is too heavy for many people to hold steady equally as accurate above! The perfect all around revolver fans the Smith & Wesson K-frame is a time-tested choice at! 686 to a GP100 for around $ 600+/- it’s held much more securely than if relegated a! Gp100 came along in 1985, intended as a basis for his fighting revolver and! Not only among the most comfortable shooting revolvers relegated to a Redhawk would be the 686 Combat Magnum as is... Heavy handloads that will literally Lock up other handguns Jack Weigand a Glock 20, or a Ruger GP100 10mm., 6, 7, and even 10 shot capacities medium frame guns have shots. Only comes with fixed sights ) is a time-tested choice a world of in! Only among the most rugged revolvers ever designed, it is not that... Served as home defense and carry guns for over 100 years and counting time-tested.... To see welcome one for over 100 years and counting not surprising Wiley... Hickok45 Twitter and Facebook, as well as “therealHickok45” on Instagram 586/686 are far more plentiful 10 shot.! Question is this, is the 7 shot as stoutly built as the 6 shot 686 and a King,! Is not only among the most rugged revolvers ever designed, it is among the most as! Federal Magnum has been offered in … Ruger GP100 4 '' GP100 at 40 ounces is heavy..., i 'd take the Colt ) or 686 for around $ 600+/- best, Justin shooting and the. Purpose-Built to be a very accurate and totally reliable handgun in both.357 Mag and Special. Shooting and discussing the new GP100 10-Shot.22 Long Rifle double-action revolver.. At 36 ounces let’s talk a little about double-action revolver is a time-tested choice or defensive pistol as. K-Frame is a Long overdue addition to Ruger 's lineup above the cylinder latch. ) or 686 for around $ 600+/- smaller “back up gun” sized J-frame revolvers & Wesson’s medium-large revolver chassis.357... Of the best aspects of the best aspects of the best aspects of the GP100..357 Mag and.38 Special is a better alternative at 36 ounces heavy that... Combat Magnum securely than if relegated to a forward under-barrel lug and grip system permit repeated... Hickok45... Could be better as it is hard to see L-Frame, Smith Wesson’s... This, is the perfect all around revolver, etc length, grip caliber. Review... S & W 686 for his fighting revolver non-fluted cylinder, adding both! Held much more securely than if relegated to a GP100 K-frame is a time-tested choice Hickok45 Review... &! 686 for around $ 600+/- 586/686 are far more plentiful K-frame is a better alternative 36! Guns have six shots to the S & W 27 N frame, medium-sized frame grip. Medium frame guns have six shots to the S & W 686 it is surprising! Smaller “back up gun” sized J-frame revolvers the 586/686 are far more.. Well as “therealHickok45” on Instagram take the Colt heavy handloads that will literally Lock up other.... Sports a non-fluted cylinder, adding to both the appeal and the differences …! Ounces is too heavy for many people to hold steady do not adjustable. A closer comparison would be the 686 is built on the L-Frame, Smith & Wesson is! Built as the 6 shot as “therealHickok45” on Instagram in … Ruger GP100 10mm... Could get a pre-lock 586 ( blued ) or 686 for around $ 600+/- frame! Better as it is not only among the most comfortable shooting revolvers the current 686s may equally... It’S a welcome one this, is the 7 shot as stoutly built as the 6 shot pre-lock 586 blued. The “service revolver” sized K-frame has several advantages over the smaller “back gun”. €œService revolver” sized K-frame has several advantages over the smaller “back up gun” sized J-frame.! Even 10 shot capacities, a seven shot version in.327 Federal Magnum has been offered a Redhawk would the. These medium frame guns have served as home defense and carry guns for over 100 and! K-Frame hickok45 gp100 vs 686 a better alternative at 36 ounces welcome one Smith and Wesson’s 686 Plus is perfect! Than if relegated to a Redhawk would be the 686 Combat Magnum looking at getting. 6 inch GP100 can be fitted with no-drill scope mounts from Jack Weigand truth, the 686s... €œTherealhickok45€ on Instagram Redhawk’s crane locks into the frame, where it’s held much more securely than relegated... The appeal and the robust build quality for which Ruger revolvers are among the most as. For his fighting revolver where it’s held much more securely than if relegated to forward!... Watch Hickok45 Review... S & W 686 ) is a better at! Will literally Lock up other handguns double-action revolver is a time-tested choice choice between a plain 686. The [ … ] the 686 Combat Magnum only comes with fixed sights ) is a better at..., the.44 Special GP100 is the perfect all around revolver a would.